← Directory

Lexington Fryer

Kips Bay · Manhattan · Bistro · $$$

French fries at Lexington Fryer
3.9Score
Very Good
Crispiness
4.5
Potato Flavor
4.5
Structural Integrity
3.0
Saltiness
3.0
Greasiness
Balanced3.5
Length
3.5
Girth
2.0
Portion Generosity
3.5

Cut Style

Thick-cut

Cooking Method

Double-fried

Oil Type

Duck fat

Price

$$$

Sauce Compatibility

ranchaioli

Location

Kips Bay, Manhattan · 40.7408, -73.9700

Critical Assessments

The crispness of the thick-cut fry at Lexington Fryer is commendable and largely sustained. This is noted first because it is noted first. The interior potato character is earnest and specific. The grease is generous in the manner of a host who means it. First impressions, in the case of the french fry, are usually correct. This one is. One visits twice. The second visit confirms the first.

R. Fontaine·November 2025

The double-fry technique employed at Lexington Fryer produces a thick-cut fry of commendable and largely sustained exterior and earnest and specific interior. The duck fat is evident and appropriate. The grease is generous in the manner of a host who means it. The portion is forthcoming. One notes the address for future reference and then, somewhat against one's usual practice, acts on it. Return visits are not a matter of choice but of inevitability.

J. Pemberton·September 2025

The thick-cut fry at Lexington Fryer has the quality of inevitability. One arrives, one orders, one encounters the crispness (commendable and largely sustained), the potato (earnest and specific), the grease (generous in the manner of a host who means it). One had not known, before this moment, that inevitability was available at this address. One knows now. One visits twice. The second visit confirms the first.

I. Talbot·May 2023

There is a school of thought that holds that a great french fry requires no accompaniment. Lexington Fryer belongs to this school. The thick-cut fry, double-fried in duck fat, makes its argument in silence. The crispness is commendable and largely sustained. The potato flavor is earnest and specific. The argument is persuasive. The address is committed to memory.

K. Stanhope·October 2025

There is a school of thought that holds that a great french fry requires no accompaniment. Lexington Fryer belongs to this school. The thick-cut fry, double-fried in duck fat, makes its argument in silence. The crispness is commendable and largely sustained. The potato flavor is earnest and specific. The argument is persuasive. One visits twice. The second visit confirms the first.

R. Throckmorton·April 2022
C

Christina's Note

An adequate entry in a crowded field. One visits with calibrated expectations.