← Directory

Gaston Antonelli's Room

Yorkville · Manhattan · Bar & Grill · $$$

French fries at Gaston Antonelli's Room
3.7Score
Very Good
Crispiness
3.0
Potato Flavor
3.5
Structural Integrity
4.5
Saltiness
3.5
Greasiness
Balanced3.5
Length
3.5
Girth
2.0
Portion Generosity
3.5

Cut Style

Curly

Cooking Method

Single-fried

Oil Type

Canola

Price

$$$

Sauce Compatibility

aiolihot saucedijon

Location

Yorkville, Manhattan · 40.7735, -73.9516

Critical Assessments

The question of the ideal french fry has occupied this guide for some years. At Gaston Antonelli's Room, one arrives closer to an answer. The curly fry, single-fried in canola, presents crispness that is adequate, which in this context constitutes a form of ambition and a potato interior that is earnest and specific. The grease is generous in the manner of a host who means it. Proximity to an answer is, in this case, sufficient. The fry asks only to be appreciated. At Gaston Antonelli's Room, one appreciates.

D. Hargreaves·May 2022

One visits Gaston Antonelli's Room for the atmosphere and departs thinking only of the fries. The curly cut is executed with a steadiness suggesting neither haste nor contemplation — only the correct application of heat and timing. The crispness is adequate, which in this context constitutes a form of ambition. The potato is earnest and specific. The grease is generous in the manner of a host who means it. One recommends not visiting for the atmosphere. This guide recommends the fries and nothing else. This is sufficient.

R. Throckmorton·July 2025

The curly fry is, at its best, a meditation on patience. Gaston Antonelli's Room understands this. The kitchen has chosen canola, which is either bold or obvious depending on one's position. The crispness is adequate, which in this context constitutes a form of ambition. The interior potato character is earnest and specific. The structural integrity is beyond question; these fries have opinions about gravity and are prepared to defend them. One returns. The address is committed to memory.

W. Cheswick·September 2023

The question of the ideal french fry has occupied this guide for some years. At Gaston Antonelli's Room, one arrives closer to an answer. The curly fry, single-fried in canola, presents crispness that is adequate, which in this context constitutes a form of ambition and a potato interior that is earnest and specific. The grease is generous in the manner of a host who means it. Proximity to an answer is, in this case, sufficient. This guide recommends the fries and nothing else. This is sufficient.

K. Stanhope·July 2022

A kitchen that single-fries in canola has made a commitment. At Gaston Antonelli's Room, this commitment is honored. The curly fry arrives crisp — adequate, which in this context constitutes a form of ambition — and earnest and specific within. The grease is generous in the manner of a host who means it. The portion is forthcoming. Commitments, when honored, tend to produce results. In the final accounting, the fries are the only item that matters. Gaston Antonelli's Room knows this.

T. Blackwood·March 2024
C

Christina's Note

An adequate entry in a crowded field. One visits with calibrated expectations.