← Directory

Old Plank

Sunset Park · Brooklyn · Continental · $$$$

French fries at Old Plank
3.9Score
Very Good
Crispiness
3.5
Potato Flavor
4.5
Structural Integrity
3.5
Saltiness
3.5
Greasiness
Restrained2.5
Length
2.0
Girth
4.5
Portion Generosity
3.5

Cut Style

Crinkle

Cooking Method

Single-fried

Oil Type

Sunflower

Price

$$$$

Sauce Compatibility

none neededtruffle mayo

Location

Sunset Park, Brooklyn · 40.6429, -74.0046

Critical Assessments

A kitchen that single-fries in sunflower has made a commitment. At Old Plank, this commitment is honored. The crinkle fry arrives crisp — commendable and largely sustained — and earnest and specific within. The grease is conservative — the napkin remains largely decorative. The portion is forthcoming. Commitments, when honored, tend to produce results. One returns.

S. Leclerc·June 2022

A certain seriousness pervades the fryer at Old Plank. The crinkle fry arrives without ceremony, which is appropriate. The exterior is commendable and largely sustained. The interior potato character is earnest and specific. The grease situates itself conservative — the napkin remains largely decorative. One proceeds. The fries are worth the journey to Sunset Park. One returns.

G. Montrose·May 2024

The crinkle fry presents itself at Old Plank with an unusual degree of self-possession. The exterior is commendable and largely sustained. The interior is earnest and specific. The grease is conservative — the napkin remains largely decorative. The portion is forthcoming. One accepts the fry on its own terms. Its terms are acceptable. The neighborhood offers alternatives. One should not investigate them.

C. Vanthorpe·November 2022
C

Christina's Note

An adequate entry in a crowded field. One visits with calibrated expectations.